Why This Miller Cannot Look Away from “The Traitors: New Blood”
By Jae-Lin Pax Ahn, Arts Editor
PAX VOBISCUM, fellow Millers.
Here in the Peaceful Collective Republic of Goldman Mill, we build our lives around the Unbroken Green. Every morning, as solar lamp posts dim along West Side Highway and the aroma of parched oats drifts out from Pastoral Court, we inhabit an intentional society explicitly engineered to reject the toxic fallout of predatory competition, raw materialism, and interpersonal cruelty. Our State Council governs through transparent consensus, our unarmed Gardai keep the peace through restorative de-escalation, and our neighbors fulfill their weekly ten-hour Service Quotas by tending communal gardens, teaching at Pax University, or assisting at the National Food Co-Op.
Which raises an uncomfortable confession for your Arts Editor on this brisk November morning, just hours after Prime Minister Regina Goldman reminded us at Harvest Fest that “Our True Harvest Is One Another”: every Thursday night, after finishing my community shift at the Miller Arts Centre, I brew a mug of chamomile tea, curl up under a hand-loomed blanket from Mirrazavi Weavers, and immerse myself in a televised shrine to deceit, paranoia, and ritualized backstabbing.
Yes, dear readers. My name is Jae-Lin Pax Ahn, and I am hopelessly addicted to “The Traitors U.S.: New Blood.”
For those sensible citizens who spend their evenings reading constitutional philosophy or tending hydroponic kale rather than streaming off-island reality television over our high-speed National Internet, allow me to explain the premise of this guilty pleasure. A group of everyday strangers—no reality-TV mercenaries or celebrity egoists this season, just “new blood” civilians—are sequestered inside a moody Scottish castle. Three among them are secretly anointed “Traitors” by our gloriously camp, tartan-draped host, Alan Cumming. Every night, the Traitors meet in a candlelit turret to “murder” one of the innocent “Faithfuls,” eliminating them from the game. Every evening before that, the entire group gathers at a cavernous Round Table to argue, accuse, weep, and banish one player they suspect of treachery.
It is, by every metric of our 1890 Constitution, the exact antithesis of the Goldman Mill ethos. Josiah Foster and Emmanuel Goldman sailed across the Atlantic to escape a world where human empathy was systematically eroded by suspicion and self-interest. Yet, watching Episode 10 this week—the penultimate chapter before next week’s grand finale—I realized that studying any of the many international varieties of “The Traitors” through a Miller lens is not merely an act of escapist indulgence. It is an anthropological reminder of why our founders drew a circle in the ocean and chose cooperation over conquest.
The Tragedy of the “Too Nice” Nurturer
Episode 10 opened in the immediate aftermath of a Round Table deadlock that laid bare the psychological rot of zero-sum games. On the chopping block were three players: Wyatt, Kriste, and Joe Vanella.
Now, in Goldman Mill, Joe Vanella—a jolly, big-hearted funeral director from New York who spent weeks lifting everyone’s spirits and keeping castle morale high—would have been elected Chair of the Hospitality Committee on his first ballot. Inside the Scottish castle, however, kindness is treated as contraband. Wyatt leveled the ultimate accusation against Joe: he was simply “too nice,” claiming that unwavering warmth and community care must surely be a calculated facade.
Joe defended himself with a line that could have been lifted straight from our Citizen Handbook: “I’m a nurturer; that’s just what I do.”
Of course, the tragic irony of “The Traitors U.S.”—and the reason it hooks even the most devoted pacifist—is that Wyatt was right. Joe was an original Traitor, having spent weeks smiling across the breakfast table while secretly signing elimination warrants by moonlight. The vting bloc, spearheaded by a tight-knit fraternity of young men alongside Abbey B. and an unexpectedly tearful Jay, turned on Joe. Jay’s sudden outpouring of grief while casting his vote immediately triggered a fresh wave of castle-wide suspicion; in an environment devoid of baseline trust, genuine human emotion looks indistinguishable from bad theater.
Joe took his banishment with remarkable grace, delivering a prepared epitaph with pure dad-joke charm: “My headstone will read: Here lies Joe, proud father, beloved husband, trrrrrrruly a great friend, and Traitor.” Watching him exit, I felt a familiar pang of Miller melancholy. Here was a man clearly built for fellowship, twisted by the architecture of a game that rewards betrayal over solidarity.
Teeny Traitor, Mega Traitor, and the Illusion of the Cloak
With both Tomica and Joe now banished, only one original Traitor remained standing: Katie Fites. Watching Katie navigate the aftermath of Joe’s ouster revealed a skilled social survivor—and a cautionary tale about how easily charm can mask manipulation.
Despite several players quietly floating the theory that a young woman might be hiding among the Traitors, Katie immediately pulled Victor aside. Victor, who had previously cracked the infamous “Fruitgate” apple-murder clue yet suffered from chronically shaky social standing, proved utterly defenseless against Katie’s warm, attentive conversation. Within minutes, she had steered his suspicions firmly toward Kriste and Jay. In our own State Court, justice relies on verifiable evidence and restorative truth-seeking; in the castle, truth bends effortlessly toward whoever offers the most flattering smile.
Because she stood alone in the turret, the rules of the game forced Katie to issue an ultimatum: recruit a Faithful to join her, or force that player to be murdered on the spot. She chose Shane Beatty, the towering, universally beloved athlete whom virtually every player in the castle trusted implicitly.
The visual comedy of the resulting turret ceremony was undeniable. Seeing the petite Katie stand beside the towering Shane as she christened their duo “Teeny Traitor and Mega Traitor” before announcing, “Let’s hood up,” was peak guilty-pleasure television. Yet beneath the giggles lies a chilling sociological truth. Shane accepted the cloak without hesitation, and within sixty seconds of swearing allegiance to his new partner, he surrendered the sacred confidence of his closest ally—revealing to Katie that Victor possessed a protective “shield” from murder.
How swiftly loyalty evaporates when survival becomes a solitary prize!
Without Victor available as a target, Teeny Traitor and Mega Traitor turned their sights on Rodeo Ben—a sweet-natured soul who had correctly suspected Katie—and signed his midnight dismissal. Breakfast the next morning was a bleak, hushed affair, stripped of joy, appetite, or camaraderie. If ever a scene illustrated why Goldman Mill de-commercialized housing, food, and basic security through our Basic Minimum Income, it was that gloomy Scottish dining room. When people are forced to fight over scarce rewards, even a plate of pastries tastes like ash.
Blindfolds, Heavy Footsteps, and Production’s Heavy Hand
As a critic writing for the Mill Messenger, I must also examine the craftsmanship of the broadcast itself—and here, even my indulgent heart has notes for the producers. Compressing the intricate social webs of “The Traitors U.S.” into a brisk 42-minute broadcast window continues to flatten the narrative, leaving viewers squinting to understand how pre-Round Table coalitions formed behind closed doors.
More troubling, however, was the episode’s central mission. Dressed in one of his most delightfully absurd ensembles—a half-and-half Victor/Victoria headpiece that deserves its own exhibit at our National Art Gallery—host Alan Cumming tasked the blindfolded Faithfuls with digging through troughs to assemble puzzle shields, while the unblindfolded Traitors crept around the room attempting to sabotage their progress.
On paper, introducing tangible physical clues into a psychological deduction game sounds clever. In execution, it felt distinctly unfair to the newly minted Mega Traitor. Clyde, already harboring sharp instincts about Katie, heard heavy footsteps thudding across the floor and a puzzle piece clattering down. By simple process of elimination—comparing the physical builds of the remaining men in the room—Clyde suddenly locked onto Shane for the very first time.
After weeks of watching the Faithfuls stumble blindly past obvious clues—including Victor and Wyatt’s endlessly baffling insistence on diagnosing midnight knocks as either “boy knocks” or “girl knocks”—having production essentially hand Clyde an acoustic blueprint of Shane’s shoe size felt like an artificial thumb on the scale. Even in a game built on deception, fairness of process matters.
Why We Watch from the Safety of the Unbroken Green
So why does a devoted citizen of the Microstate of Peace, someone who believes wholeheartedly in nonviolence, mutual aid, and the quiet dignity of collective labor, find such magnetic pleasure in watching strangers lie to one another on a screen?
Perhaps it is because art—even glossy, melodramatic reality television—serves as a safe mirror for the impulses our society has consciously outgrown. In Goldman Mill, we have eradicated the structural incentives for greed, backstabbing, and fear. We do not have to hoard resources, weaponize affection, or banish our neighbors to secure our children’s future. Watching “The Traitors U.S.: New Blood” from the comfort of our solar-powered homes is a bit like observing a thunderstorm from behind thick, double-paned glass: We can marvel at the flash of lightning and the rumble of thunder without ever getting wet.
As the series hurtles toward next week’s finale, the castle stands on a knife’s edge. Will Teeny Traitor and Mega Traitor outmaneuver Clyde’s sharp ears and Victor’s stubborn intuition to claim the pot, or will the remaining Faithfuls finally unite in genuine solidarity to unmask them?
I will certainly tune in next Thursday—right after my evening shift at the arts centre, of course. And when the credits roll and the castle doors slam shut, I will step back out onto the tranquil paths of the Unbroken Green, grateful beyond measure that in our corner of the Atlantic, the only thing we conspire to share is the harvest.
Pax Vobiscum, Millers.
Jae-Lin Pax Ahn is the Arts & Culture Editor for the Mill Messenger. Views expressed in “Ahn TV: Guilty Pleasures & Peaceful Minds” are those of the columnist and do not represent the official position of the Ministry of Peace-Values-Education.




Leave a Reply